• BVI, Ireland, Jersey, London, Panama, South Africa
  • enquiries@hatstone.com
  • Home
  • Our Services
    • BVI
      • Fund Administration
      • Corporate Services
      • Investment Funds
      • Legal & Other Services
        • Banking and Finance
        • Capital Markets
        • Corporate & Commercial
        • Family Office Services
        • Legal Opinions
        • Litigation
        • Private Client
        • Regulatory Advice
      • View Our Other Services
      • Terms and Conditions BVI
    • Ireland
      • Finance & Banking Solicitors
      • Property Law
      • Company & Corporate Law
      • Litigation & Dispute Resolution in Ireland
      • Employment Law
      • Private Client
      • View Our Other Services
    • Jersey
      • Capital Markets
      • Corporate and Commercial
      • Digital Media, IP and eGaming
      • Employment
      • Investment Funds
      • Legal Opinions
      • Litigation & Dispute Resolution
      • Private Client
      • View Our Other Services
    • Panama
      • Companies
      • Construction
      • Corporate and Commercial Panama
      • Debt Recovery
      • Employment
      • Foundations
      • Immigration
      • Investment Funds
      • Ship Registration
      • View Our Other Services
    • South Africa
      • Corporate and Commercial
      • Employment Law
      • Family Law
      • Litigation
      • Mediation
      • Private Client
      • Regulatory & Compliance
      • View Our Other Services
  • Our People
    • BVI
      • BVI Corporate ServicesCalum McKenzie
        Phone: +1 284 494 7065
        Email: calum.mckenzie@hatstone.com
      • BVI Fund AdministrationDaniel Cann
        Phone: +507 830 5300
        Email: daniel.cann@hatstone.com
      • Philipp Neumann
        Phone: +1284 494 47 17
        Email: philipp.neumann@hatstone.com
      • View all BVI Staff
    • Ireland
      • Grainne Loughnane
        Phone: 01 902 6776 (DDi)
        Email: grainne.loughnane@hatstone.com
      • Julie O Sullivan
        Phone: 01 482 6098 (DDi)
        Email: julie.osullivan@hatstone.com
      • View all Ireland Staff
    • Jersey
      • Alexander English promotedAlexander English
        Phone: +44 1534 761180
        Email: alexander.english@hatstone.com
      • Carl O’Shea
        Phone: +44 1534 761182 (DDi)
        Email: carl.oshea@hatstone.com
      • top private client firmSimon Vivian
        Phone: +44 1534 761186 (DDi)
        Email: simon.vivian@hatstone.com
      • View all Jersey Staff
    • Panama
      • Alvaro Almengor
        Phone: +507 830 5300
        Email: alvaro.almengor@hatstone.com
      • Lizst Real
        Phone: +507 830 5300
        Email: lizst.real@hatstone.com
      • View all Panama Staff
    • South Africa
      • Hannes Botha
        Phone: +27 21 880 9393
        Email: hannes.botha@hatstone.com
      • Daléne Botha
        Phone: +27 21 880 9391
        Email: dalene.botha@hatstone.com
      • Menko Hoeksema
        Phone: +27 21 880 9391
        Email: menko.hoeksema@hatstone.com
      • View all South Africa Staff
  • Our Locations
    • BVI – Hatstone
    • Ireland
    • Jersey
    • London
    • Panama
    • South Africa
  • Media
    • BVI
      • BVI – Economic Substance: Enforcement and penalties for non-compliance
        Posted on 11/06/2021
      • BVI corporate counselHatstone appoints new corporate counsel for its BVI office
        Posted on 11/06/2021
      • Hatstone’s BVI team advises the Bank of London and The Middle East plc
        Posted on 27/01/2021
      • View All
    • Ireland
      • Hatstone crowned ‘Best Internationl Law Firm’
        Posted on 09/11/2021
      • Hatstone Lawyers in Dublin Press Release
        Posted on 06/01/2022
      • Hatstone advises Team PLCHatstone Lawyers Advise AIM Listed Team PLC
        Posted on 06/01/2022
      • View All
    • Jersey
      • Hatstone shortlisted as the Jersey Law Firm of the Year in the Citywealth International Financial Centre Awards
        Posted on 11/01/2021
      • Hatstone shortlisted as the Jersey Law Firm of the Year
        Posted on 11/01/2021
      • COVID-19 – Update on Business Restrictions – The Law Society of Jersey excerpt
        Posted on 13/01/2021
      • View All
    • Panama
      • Panama ImmigrationPanama Update – Immigration
        Posted on 08/07/2021
      • Panama TaxPanama Update – Tax and Real Estate
        Posted on 08/07/2021
      • Home Sweet Home by Alvaro Almengor and Manuel Carrasquilla
        Posted on 22/12/2020
      • View All
    • South Africa
      • top private client firmHatstone named as one of the world’s top private client firms
        Posted on 27/10/2020
      • international wealth diversificationOffshore trustees: How to add value to your South African client at little cost to your company
        Posted on 26/10/2020
      • Qualified AttorneysMust Read: How the pending 2021 amendment will affect South African emigration and retirement funds.
        Posted on 26/10/2020
      • View All
  • Publications
  • Contact Us
  • Home
  • Opinion Piece
  • The curious case of Webb v Webb

The curious case of Webb v Webb

  • 11/12/2020

If you want to have your cake and eat it, take a slice or two, not the whole cake.

There has been lot of noise generated by the Supreme Court decision in Webb v Webb* regarding the settlor reserved powers aspect of the case, little of which is worth the airtime. Many practitioners have been warning for years about taking liberties with reserved powers and the danger of stretching the concept too far. Like an elastic band, stretch it far enough and it will snap.

About the case

In this case, reserving a personal (as oppose to fiduciary) power for Mr Webb to declare at any time that he was the only beneficiary of the Trust made it an easy decision that he had failed to make an effective disposition of property as the rights he enjoyed in respect of the trust assets were indistinguishable from personal ownership. Had he not had this power, then it would have been interesting, based on the extensive other powers he had reserved, to see whether he had created a valid trust or not.

Prudent practitioners have always had reservations about taking things to extremes, whether it be about trying to oust the responsibilities for which a professional trustee is paid (as in Zhang v DBS – can you really have a trustee with no obligation whatsoever for oversight?), or about creating trusts with so many reserved powers that you scratch your head and wonder whether it is a trust, or any form of disposition, at all. It’s good to see the courts across the world putting the brakes on. If you want to have your cake and eat it, take a slice or two, not the whole cake.

The more interesting aspect of the case was the tax point, which was considered in the context of whether a New Zealand tax debt should be taken into account in determining the value of matrimonial property situated in the Cook Islands. The debt was found to be unenforceable in the Cook Islands,

The conclusion (by 2-1 Lord Wilson dissenting) confirmed that you cannot enforce one country’s tax judgment abroad. This is an entirely conventional principle but interesting in this case because of the legislative and constitutional relationship between the Cook Islands and New Zealand, more particularly section 655 of the Cook Islands Act 1915, which states that “Bankruptcy in New Zealand shall have the same effect in respect to property situated in the Cook Islands as if that property was situated in New Zealand”.

Mr Webb had been declared bankrupt with the main judgment debtor being the Commissioner of the Inland Revenue. It is highly arguable that the Commissioner should have been in the same position as any other judgement debtor in bankruptcy looking to enforce their rights under section 655.

* Webb v Webb (Cook Islands) 2020 UKPC 22

  • jersey
  • London
  • Panama
  • Private Client
  • Share:
Hatstone

Bio info goes here.

Previous Article: Innovation in Funds – A Hive of Activity
Next Article Practical considerations for the use of electronic signatures in Jersey

Hatstone operations

Quick Links

  • About Us
  • Careers
  • Our Operations
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Notice

Our Locations

  • BVI – Hatstone
  • Ireland
  • Jersey
  • London
  • Panama
  • South Africa

Subscribe to Hatstone's Newsletter

© Copyright | Hatstone Group | All right reserved | Powered by Fresh Mango Technologies